Maui Recycling Service

IF NOT NOW, WHEN?


GOVERNMENT TOTALLY FAILS RECYCLING EFFORT

The last couple of years have been extremely difficult for the recycling infrastructure on Maui.  First, we are no longer able to compost paper at Maui EKO, nor cardboard at Apana’s, resulting in a new very high tipping fee for both.  Also, instead of being paid $10 per ton to haul glass (the non-HI 5 glass like wine/liquor bottles and food containers) we are forced to pay up to $90 a ton to unload our commodity and to compensate, we must add a surcharge which effectively double-charges for glass recycling (See our website for details).  Our government has completely failed us.  These past few years have shown, beyond any doubt, that our County and State governments do not care about recycling.  They only care about appearances.  If you doubt this statement, ask yourself why we are guaranteed a county owned and operated landfill to dump "trash" but there is no County sponsored recycling processing facility of any kind to divert material from our dwindling landfill space?  This State, being made of small islands, could easily be one of the forerunners in the recycling world but excuses, inactivity, and letting someone else deal with it seems like the most common “action” from the government.  One would think that over time our recycling infrastructure would improve at least a little, and certainly not go down the drain like it has over the past two years.  We need our County Counsel to create a Material Recovery Facility (MRF) now!    A County owned MRF was supposed to be up and running by January 2006! Money was budgeted and spent for this purpose, but, for some reason, they gave up on it.  The absolute total apathy of our Government on behalf of recycling is stunning.  They simply do not care about taking the necessary steps to increase the recycling rate.  Last October 3rd the Maui News published a front page story about the landfill overflowing by December 2006 largely due to the fact that the current diversion rate is less than 20%!  The County claims roughly 28% diversion but those numbers include scrapped cars, and appliances, which no-one else uses in figuring their diversion rates .  Maybe this type of dishonest number bandying has something to do with the lack of integrity surrounding the government’s slipshod mishandling of the solid waste system.  This could all be solved by drastically raising the landfill tipping fees to generate the revenues necessary to fund diversion processes without dipping into the general fund.   Three separate studies over the past 12 years have indicated this to be the critical factor.  Why has the County Council ignored theses studies?  Why do the County and State continuously and caustically fight each other with regard to such an essential service not unlike water, sewer, power, police, and firefighters?  Obviously, our government officials don’t care how much money is wasted since they will receive their paychecks, whether the landfill operates or not.  After all, it’s not their money that’s being squandered.                    

Please write to the elected officials listed. Share your anger and disappointment and demand that a County sponsored MRF be built immediately!  Also, please write to the Governor and demand that she work to improve the recycling effort instead of her continued opposition to good recycling programs (like the Bottle Bill/HI 5 program).

 Maui Recycling Service is a small company that simply does not have the resources to solve all of the recycling problems we face, besides, we don’t think that good people,            like our customers, should be forced to pay more and more and hold the burden for the rest of this society, just because they have a conscience, or own a bar and are forced to recycle glass, whatever the cost. This is and has been a crisis for Maui County for well over ten years.  How many decades must pass before an honest straightforward competent system is in place? 

 



The following is a copy of a letter sent to the Governor
 and other officials.
As of today, still no reply....

If not now, when?


Governor Linda Lingle                                                                           
February 12, 2007

Executive Chambers
Hawaii State
Capitol
Honolulu , HI 96813

Governor Lingle,

 

I have been informed that the funding for the Advanced Disposal Fee (ADF) on glass (glass not covered by the State Bottle Bill Program) will be several months short for Maui this fiscal year, effectively ending at the end last month (January 2007).  The State Legislature and your office approved a raid of the ADF Environmental Management Special Fund of $2,000,000 in 2004.  In the form of Act 52, section 14:

 

“…section 14.  The legislature determines that there is in the environmental management special fund at least $2,000,000 in excess of the requirements of the fund…”

 

Act 52 made the false claim that there was an excess of $2 million in the fund, when in fact, there was no excess in the fund as witnessed by the fact that they ran out of money.  Since there never was an excess, the $2 million needs to be replaced so that Maui ’s bars, restaurants and ultimately patrons aren’t further discriminated against, and especially since there is a general fund surplus this year.  Additionally, an investigation should be conducted to find out how such a fraudulent determination of excess funds could have been made.

 

Maui County mandated glass recycling, requiring bars and restaurants to recycle glass.  The raid of the fund effectively double charges these businesses even though they are already doing their part.  And Maui County recyclers are penalized further because the distribution of ADF funds is based on population, and Maui County has the highest glass recycling rate in the State.  

 

The County & State recycling offices have told me that there is no recourse on this matter, and that I should just pass the higher costs of glass recycling onto our glass recycling customers (hotels, bars, restaurants, etc.), who already paid in ‘advance‘ to recycle glass.  The ADF fund is specifically for glass recycling:

 

“Moneys from the special account shall be used to fund county glass recovery programs established in accordance with the requirements under section 342G-86”

 

There are three actions the State can take to correct the glass recycling problems we face on Maui :

          Restore the $2 million mistakenly taken from the ADF fund in 2004

          Revise the Bottle Bill to include most glass containers, and/or a commingled rate for glass

          Change the ADF law to distribute the ADF funds based on a variety of factors, including defacto population and glass recycling rate

 

I look forward to your response and your action on this very important issue.

 

Sincerely,

 

Shaun Stenshol

President

Maui Recycling Service, Inc.








The ADF Law

  §342G-84  Deposit into environmental management special fund; distribution to counties.  (a)  Revenues generated from the advance disposal fee shall be deposited into a special account in the environmental management fund.  Moneys from the special account shall be used to fund county glass recovery programs established in accordance with the requirements under section 342G-86; provided that no moneys shall be made available to a county unless the county has first submitted its formally adopted integrated solid waste management plan to the department for review.  In the event of any surplus in the special account, the department shall recommend a reduction in the fee as deemed necessary.

     (b)  The department shall distribute the moneys contained in the special account to the counties in proportion to the amount of glass imported into each county based on the county's de facto population.  The distribution shall be in the form of direct contracts with the department as permitted under chapters 103 and 103D or transfer of funds from the department.

     (c)  No more than ten per cent, in the aggregate, of the revenue collected in any one year may be used by the department for administrative and educational purposes and to promote glass recovery, recycling, and reuse in Hawaii through research and demonstration projects.

     (d)  All moneys distributed to the counties under subsection (b), and not used by the counties as specified in section 342G-86, shall be returned to the State for deposit into the environmental management special fund at the end of each annual contract period. [L 1994, c 201, pt of §2; am L 1998, c 253, §1; am L 2002, c 176, §11]



The law the governor passed to raid the ADF fund


Click here for Contacts

Please share your thoughts, your anger, and disappointment with the whole system.
Together we can make a difference, and help make Maui an even better place.

 
 

Maui Recycling Service

Dedicated to local and global sustainability 

P.O. Box 1267

Wailuku, Hi. 96793

(808) 244-0443 Fax (808) 244-0614

info@mauirecycles.com